Three cookies came, but only one was crowned Buffalo's Best Christmas Cookie and walked away with a huge gift basket from Muscoreil's in North Tonawanda. The winning cookie was the Sea Salt and Caramel Treasures made by Tammy Comerate.

Thank you also to our runners up: Kendra Catalano and her Scotch Nog Stars and Donna Frost for her Heavenly Cutout Cookies for coming out and cooking with us! Check out all the deliciousness!